When you think about home improvements, it’s important to think about how, when you bought your home, certain factors helped make your decision.

First of all, you probably had a list of dealbreakers. These are things you either couldn’t live with, or couldn’t live without. They’re different for everybody, but probably took the form of:

I can’t live next to __________________
I need a house that has at least ___ bedrooms
I need a house that has at least ___ bathrooms
I absolutely need garage space for ___ cars
I could never see myself in a house that doesn’t have, or the potential for ________________

These are the needs of your home buying process.

Additionally, you were probably looking at more than one house that met your deal-breakers, so you decided you had some wants as well for the house. Wants can take the form of any number of items but are usually stated like:

I would be willing to pay extra for a house that had ___________________
If I could get a house with ________________, I might stay there forever
If this house has the possibility for ________________, we’d definitely make that improvement immediately!

Some home improvements make a big difference in saleability

When you added up the wants and needs and made a decision to buy a home, you validated choices made by previous owners all the way back to the day blueprints were drafted.

You may have especially loved the four seasons room that the previous owners discussed for weeks before deciding to add. Maybe, the included fireplace was a dealbreaker for you, and it was almost taken out back in 1983.

Now that you own the home, it’s becoming apparent that decisions you make about your home every day could mean selling it for a great price, or having to labor in the market with an unsold home.

The key here is saleability.

Saleability is the ability of your home to sell! It has a few factors, but primarily involves discovering what amounts to dealbreakers for the majority of the population and prioritizing these improvements.

If your home needs major repairs, have them done first as it’s more likely that these items will be deal-breakers for prospective buyers.

wrecked home

If your house looks like this, it may be too late.

If you’re familiar with your neighborhood and desired price market, you may know of other changes that will likely meet the dealbreakers of prospective buyers.

Think of a finished basement. If most homes in your neighborhood or price range have a finished basement, this is likely going to be a dealbreaker for many buyers.

Which home improvements have the best return on investment?

Getting beyond saleability and addressing likely dealbreakers, when it comes to making decisions about which home improvements to make, it’s helpful to know which ones are likely to return on their investment.

The majority of this data in this blog is from Remodeling’s 2016 Cost Vs Value Report. Every percentage is given in relation to the investment made and not the total value of the home.

For instance,

Finished basements are likely to provide a 72.8% return on investment. If you spend $16,322.00 to finish the basement on a home you’re listing for $183,000 , you’re able to pass 72.8% back to the buyer.

This improvement could increase the value of your home by $11,882.42, giving you a new total of $194,882.42.

Why make improvements that return less than 100% on investment?

This is a great question! There are a couple of answers:

Number one, making improvements is likely to address any dealbreakers homebuyers might have.

You may only recover 72.8% of what you paid to finish your basement, but it also might mean getting 2 prospective buyers into a bidding war for a home that they all would have passed over because the basement was unfinished before.

beautiful home with flowers

Number two, these improvements have a synergistic effect on both the saleability and the desirability of the home. So while your finished attic, finished basement and massive kitchen overhaul don’t individually add up to 100% return on investments, the premium look and feel of the home is more likely to attract more buyers with bigger budgets.

Finally, you get to enjoy all of these things in the time you’re spending living in the home before you put it up for sale – whether that’s 5 months, or 15 years!

Okay, I get it…so how much do common improvements return?

How much do roof improvements return on investment?

Roof improvements can be considered a saleability issue in many cases. Prospective homebuyers may be reluctant about investing in a home with a failing roof. If the roof is in good condition, however, replacement will see the following returns on investment:

Asphalt Shingles: 71.9 %
Steel Shingles:  85.9%*

* Steel shingles are likely to return more over the life of the roof as they last much longer than asphalt. Your prospective buyers, barring them being vampires, will probably never need to replace the roof in their lifetime.

How much does exterior paint return on investment?

A fresh coat of exterior paint can have one of the biggest impacts on the price of your home. Additionally, it will enhance the home’s curb appeal which may rope in some initially uninterested passers-by and turn them into prospective buyers.

Neutral paint: 250%

Using a neutral color provides a welcoming and safe feeling for prospective buyers. Looking to add personality? Think about colorful shutters, trim or door and windows.

What about siding?

In the great midwest, siding is a crucial part of any home. A one-time investment pays off since it is likely cheaper than the sum of even one or two damages a house will incur without it.

Vinyl siding: 83%
Fibre-cement siding: 79%

Turning an attic into a bedroom?

While you will definitely want to consult with a roofing company before finishing an attic (making sure you’re not setting yourself up for ice dams), it can be a very lucrative improvement.

Bedroom attic conversion

Additionally, this improvement adds an entire new bedroom to your home increasing the number of people searching for it.

Bedroom – attic conversion: 77.2%

The two big ones – bathroom and kitchen renovations

Your kitchen and bathroom are two rooms by which homebuyers will judge and remember your home. Investing time and money into making these rooms beautiful/design showroom pieces pays off on an emotional level with prospective homebuyers.

Bath remodel

Statistically, the financial return is a bit lower, but in premium markets it can be well over 100%.

Kitchen remodel: 67.8%
Bathroom remodel: 72.8%

Home-staging experts recommend trying to make your kitchen as clean and sterile-looking as possible. In the bathroom, make visitors feel like they are in an upscale spa.

Beautiful Kitchen in Mountain Home Location

Landscaping is king, however

Good landscaping is another improvement that immediately increase curb appeal and is therefore likely to immediately grab buyers. It’s also, statistically, a very smart investment.

Landscaping: 150%

Which is on the low end. John Gidding, host of “Curb Appeal” on HGTV, has described a situation in which a $20,000 investment in landscaping increased the selling price of a home by $200,000. So yeah, it’s a great investment.

Landscaping can be a huge boost for home value

Landscaping is undeniably one of the best investments for home value

Get a free estimate on your home!

If you’re worried about the saleability of your home, and want to get any potential deal-breakers straightened out, let us know.

Maybe you’re just looking to increase the value with some smart roofing and gutter improvements.

Contact us today for a free estimate. Click the button below!

Get a free estimate

Treating Your Roof Like it is Our Own

We’re the most trusted roofing contractor in Northeast Wisconsin.
Owens Corning Platinum Partner.
Owens Corning Platinum Partner.
Full 50-year warranty, guaranteed.
Full 50-year warranty, guaranteed.
60+ years of experience with high quality materials and craftsmanship.
60+ years of experience with high quality materials and craftsmanship.

Free Estimate

Protect your most valuable asset and get a no strings attached free estimate and see if your roof qualifies a repair.


Get Your Free Estimate

Free Estimates

Services We Provide

Residential Roofing

Asphalt shingles, stone coated steel and low slope membranes with guaranteed roofing durability and an unrivaled warranty.

Learn More

Gutter Topper

Keeps out leaves and other debris to let your gutters flow freely

Learn More

Commercial Roofing

The local roofing experts for businesses in Northeast Wisconsin.

Learn More

Service Department

Our expert technicians are equipped to solve any roofing problem.

Learn More

The Quality Roof You Deserve From a Company You Can Trust.

Top-of-the-line materials and craftsmanship, at Security-Luebke Roofing we’ve given clients peace of mind for over 60+ years.

Experienced and Knowledgeable: Our team has seen it all when it comes to roofing, thanks to our 60+ years in the Fox Valley. We get the job done right the first time.

Responsive: Sometimes, repairs to your roof can't wait. Our dedicated team provides prompt communication and repair so you can enjoy your home while it is safe and warm.

No Traces Left Behind: After our crew is done with the job, we bring your yard to the way it was when we arrived - no nails, shingles, or materials left behind. We leave only the new durable roof. If anything is found, we will come back to make it right.

Rainy Day Financing: We offer a variety of options to fit your budget.

Our Story

Learn about our 60-year history of the best craftsmanship and safety. Homeowners, businesses and organizations from Green Bay, Appleton, Manitowoc, Oshkosh and the surrounding areas can expect us to provide unmatched roofing excellence. With outstanding quality and 60+ years of experience, we are able to provide you with only the best in new roofs, roof repair and leading gutter guard solutions

Our Team

We are the local experts in everything roofing. From shingles to steel, our experienced team has seen it all, and done it all. Our team is what sets us apart from any other roofing and gutter contractors in Wisconsin. With over 50,000 customers over 60 years, we are highly experienced and knowledgeable. Allow our roofing family to provide you with excellent service and a high-quality roof your family deserves.

Security-Luebke Roofing
"The Best company bar none from beginning to end and everything in between."

"Best roof inspection/ overview I have ever seen. I felt completely educated concerning my roof concerns and very capable of making a educated decision in my purchase. Very impressive company and a very impressive warranty."

- Scott Vilski

"From start to finish they were very professional and thorough. Explained everything in detail, laid out all my options and helped decide which one was best for us!"

"The Crew worked hard was very professional and did an amazing job on clean up!!! Left no traces that they were there!!!"

- Kyle Liesch

"I'm very pleased with the service. Their sales person, brought in samples of the different types materials that they could install and explained the benefits of each in laymen's terms. Once on the roof Their crew was very fast, efficient and professional. Great work!"

- Max Herman

Our Process

Fill out a form or give us a call. We will make sure to get someone out to your property as soon as possible.
We will send a member of our team out to inspect your roof and determine what your roof needs as well as answer any questions you may have.
A new roof is a big investment, our hassle-free process allows you to make a decision once you are comfortable.
After you’ve made your decision, our residential estimator will inform you when we can start your project.

Platinum Preferred Owens Corning Contractor

Owens Corning is a global leader in building materials and is known for their high standards for craftmanship and service.

We are distinguished as an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred roofing contractor, allowing us to offer one of the most prestigious warranties in the roofing industry. All new roof installations are backed by a 50-year non-prorated warranty.

Our Locations

Appleton, WI

Appleton, WI

Green Bay, WI

Green Bay, WI

Oshkosh, WI

Oshkosh, WI

Checklist Guide to Hiring the Right Contractor

Download Our Contract Checklist

Professional Affiliations